The Pros and Cons of Synthetic Roofing Materials

Synthetic roofing materials—also called composite roofing—have seen a rise in popularity due to their durability, design versatility, and eco-friendly appeal. Made from polymers, rubber, recycled plastics, or a combination of materials, synthetic roofing is designed to mimic traditional roofing types like slate, cedar shake, or clay tile without the associated downsides. But are synthetic materials right for your home or project? In this guide, we break down the key pros and cons of synthetic roofing, how it compares to natural materials, and what to look for in a contractor.

What Are Synthetic Roofing Materials?

Synthetic roofing products are man-made alternatives designed to look like natural materials. These include:

• Synthetic slate tiles (made from recycled plastic, rubber, or polymers)
• Faux cedar shakes (engineered to mimic wood but resist rot and insects)
• Rubber or polymer-based shingles (lightweight, textured, often reflective)
• Composite tiles (made of various synthetic blends, reinforced for strength)

These materials are engineered to last longer, weigh less, and often include UV inhibitors, fire retardants, and impact-resistant components.

Advantages of Synthetic Roofing

1. Durability

Synthetic roofs are built to withstand severe weather, including high winds, hail, and UV exposure. Many products come with Class 4 impact ratings (the highest available) and Class A fire resistance.

2. Lightweight

Unlike slate or clay tile, which may require structural reinforcements, synthetic roofing is much lighter and can typically be installed on existing framing.

3. Design Flexibility

Modern manufacturing techniques allow synthetic products to replicate the look and texture of natural materials with stunning accuracy. Many are indistinguishable from real slate or wood from ground level.

4. Low Maintenance

Synthetic roofs resist mold, rot, insects, and splitting. They don’t require the treatments or upkeep associated with natural wood or slate.

5. Eco-Friendly Options

Many synthetic roofing products are made from recycled materials and are recyclable at the end of their lifespan. Brands like DaVinci and Brava emphasize sustainability in their production processes.

6. Long Warranties

Manufacturers typically offer 30 to 50-year warranties. The long lifespan means lower lifetime cost and fewer replacements.

Potential Drawbacks

1. Cost

While cheaper than natural slate or tile, synthetic roofing is more expensive than asphalt shingles. It sits in the mid-to-premium range in terms of price per square foot.

2. Limited Long-Term Data

Although most modern synthetic roofing materials are rigorously tested, some have only been on the market for a couple of decades. They don’t have the centuries-long track record of slate or clay.

3. Color Fade

Over time, synthetic products can experience fading due to UV exposure—though most now include fade-resistant technology or coatings.

4. Not All Products Are Equal

Quality can vary widely between manufacturers. Cheaper brands may skimp on materials or finish, leading to cracking or warping over time.

5. Requires Skilled Installation

Synthetic materials often have different installation requirements than asphalt or metal. An experienced contractor is essential to ensure warranty compliance and long-term performance.

Regional Suitability: Where Synthetic Roofing Excels

The versatility of synthetic materials makes them suitable across many climates, but some regions may see even greater benefits:

Cold and Snowy Climates

In northern states like Minnesota, Michigan, and Colorado, synthetic roofing’s resistance to freeze/thaw cycles, cracking, and impact (from snow or hail) is a major advantage. Faux slate and shake offer the aesthetics of traditional materials without becoming brittle in extreme cold.

Coastal and Humid Areas

In southeastern coastal regions such as Florida, Georgia, and the Carolinas, high humidity and salt air can deteriorate natural wood or metal. Synthetic shake and tile resist moisture, mold, and mildew without warping or rotting. Class A fire ratings are also a benefit in wildfire-prone coastal zones.

Storm-Prone Regions

Synthetic roofing with Class 4 impact ratings performs well in areas prone to hail and windstorms, such as Texas, Oklahoma, and the central Midwest. Its lightweight nature also reduces risk in severe storms and minimizes the chance of shingle detachment.

Hot and Sunny Climates

In southwestern states like Arizona, Nevada, and Southern California, synthetic roofing materials that include UV inhibitors help maintain color stability and structural integrity. Reflective coating options also help reduce cooling loads in desert climates.

Historic Districts and HOA-Regulated Areas

In neighborhoods where the look of slate or shake is required, but weight and maintenance are concerns, synthetic materials offer a compliant and practical alternative. They help meet aesthetic guidelines without compromising durability or adding structural challenges.

Popular Brands and Products

• DaVinci Roofscapes – Known for their synthetic slate and shake products with high impact ratings and vibrant color blends.
• Brava Roof Tile – Offers composite Spanish barrel tile, cedar shake, and slate options with strong environmental credentials.
• EcoStar – Offers recycled rubber-based synthetic slate with sustainable manufacturing processes.
• InSpire Roofing – Offers Class A fire-rated synthetic slate with UV-stable color.

‍

When Is Synthetic Roofing the Right Choice?

• You want the aesthetic of slate, tile, or shake but need to stay within a moderate budget
• Your home can’t support heavy roofing materials
• You live in an area prone to hail, wildfire, or severe storms
• You prefer a lower-maintenance option
• You want a sustainable solution that balances performance and environmental responsibility

Red Flags and Mistakes to Avoid

• Choosing based on looks alone without checking impact/fire ratings
• Hiring a contractor unfamiliar with the brand’s installation specs
• Ignoring warranty registration requirements
• Overlooking attic ventilation needs, especially in hot climates

Questions to Ask Before Choosing Synthetic Roofing

• What is the total installed cost compared to other materials?
• What warranty is included—and what voids it?
• How does this product perform in my local climate?
• Can I see physical samples or homes you’ve installed this on?
• Is the product certified for fire, hail, or wind resistance?

‍